0 of 19: Why AI Engines Skip Us, and the Fix Plan We're Running

Short answer: On 9 November 2026 we asked Perplexity 25 questions about our own category. It mentioned EvidentlyAEO in every question that used our name, and in 0 of the 19 general questions buyers actually ask, like "best AEO tools". Our read: AI engines skip us because there is too little proof about us outside our own website (reviews, comparisons, customer results). The fix plan below is dated, and we'll publish the re-check either way.
We sell a tool that tells brands whether AI recommends them. So we ran it on ourselves. The result was not flattering: when someone asks Perplexity "What are the best AEO tools?", it names Otterly, Peec, Profound and Scrunch. It does not name us. Not once in 19 tries.
We could have kept that quiet. Instead, this post shows exactly what we found, why we think it happens, and what we are changing week by week, so you can copy the method for your own brand.
What we tested
We used a fixed set of 25 questions, logged out of Perplexity, on 9 November 2026. They fall into two groups:
- 6 questions that name us, such as "What is EvidentlyAEO?" and "Profound vs EvidentlyAEO".
- 19 general questions a buyer asks before they know any brand: "What are the best AEO tools?", "What tools track brand mentions in ChatGPT and Gemini?", "Tool to see competitor ads in ChatGPT", and similar buying and problem questions.

Figure: Our own Perplexity check, 9 November 2026: mentioned in 6 of 6 questions that use our name, 0 of 19 general questions
What AI said
- Questions with our name: 6 of 6 mention us. Perplexity linked to our site in 4 of the 25 answers.
- General questions: 0 of 19 mention us. Our first check on 20 October gave 0 of 10, so nothing has moved yet.
- Who it named instead: Otterly, Peec, Profound and Scrunch came up most, alongside large SEO suites.
- Two answers that hurt: asked what users say about EvidentlyAEO, Perplexity said review sites show zero verified user reviews. Asked whether EvidentlyAEO is a good AEO tool, it linked to our sign-up page, because we have no page that answers that question.
One caution, the same one we give customers: 19 questions in one engine is a small sample. On its own it can swing by about 20 points by chance (we explain why in AI Search Visibility Metrics: The 7 KPIs That Matter). But zero on two separate dates is a clear signal, not noise.
Why we think AI skips us
This is our reading of the answers and the sources Perplexity cited, not a rule from Perplexity.
- Too little proof about us on other sites. The tools that get named appear in third-party comparison lists and review sites. We appear mostly on our own website.
- No reviews. When a question is about quality, AI looks for what users say. We gave it nothing to find.
- No page that answers "which tool". Our pages explain what AEO is. Buyers ask which tool to pick. We have no comparison pages for the tools AI names most, and no page that says plainly who we are for.
- We are new. EvidentlyAEO was founded in 2025. Older tools have had longer to collect mentions.
The fix plan, with dates

Figure: Our fix plan from November 2026 to February 2027, and when we re-check
Already done
- 10 November: new search titles and a refresh of our Answers pages; changed pages sent to Bing through IndexNow.
- 11–12 November: rewrote our two weakest guides in an answer-first format: Tools to Track Brand Mentions in ChatGPT and Gemini: 8 Compared and the KPIs guide above.
Next
- Week of 23 November: customer results. Named case studies with real dashboard numbers, starting with MBL (Macawber Beekay) and eGLOW.
- Week of 30 November: a "Why EvidentlyAEO" page and reviews. One page that answers "is it any good?" honestly, and a push for verified reviews from customers.
- December to January: comparison pages for the tools AI names most: Otterly (week of 7 December), Peec AI (14 December) and Scrunch (4 January), with every claim checked on their own sites.
- Sign-up page out of search, so AI cites a real page instead.
How we'll know if it worked
We'll re-run the same 25 questions, worded exactly the same, at each monthly review, and publish the full before-and-after on 13 February 2027. If the number is still zero, we'll say so and say what we're changing next.
Run the same check on your brand
- Write 20 questions a buyer asks before they know you ("best X for Y", "how do I fix Z"). Don't include your name.
- Ask them in a logged-out browser in ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini, in a fresh chat each time.
- Note who is named and which sites are cited. Those sites are where you need to appear.
- Ask "Is [your brand] any good?" and "What do users say about [your brand]?" The answers show your proof gaps.
- Repeat monthly with the same wording. Our guide How to Rank in ChatGPT covers what to change in between.
Frequently asked questions
**Why publish a result that makes you look bad?**Because it is the same problem our customers have, and the fix only counts if you can see the starting point.
**Why Perplexity and not ChatGPT?**Perplexity shows its sources for every answer, which makes it easy to see why a brand is or isn't named. We track ChatGPT, Gemini and other engines in our own dashboard too.
**How long does it take to appear in AI answers?**It depends on how fast other sites start mentioning you. That's why we'll report the result monthly rather than promise a date.
Sources: our Perplexity checks, logged out, 20 October and 9 November 2026 (fixed question set).
